Regina Doman on Deathly Hallows

Regina Doman wrote an essay in 2005 called “Harry Potter for Catholics?”. This eloquent defense of Ms. Rowling’s books, coming as it did in the wake of the supposed condemnation of Ms. Rowling’s books by the Pope, was a watershed event in keeping Harry off many parishes’ unofficial but very real list of Proscribed Books. Now she has written an intensely personal review of Deathly Hallows for Sean Dailey of the Blue Boar weBlog. Knowing that I was eager to read what she thought of the last book, Mrs. Doman sent me a copy of this letter to post here as well.

Ms. Rowling said in an interview post Goblet of Fire that she was gratified to learn that her books had become some comfort to those grieving the death of a loved one. I had forgotten her comment but, after reading the finish of Deathly Hallows and Mrs. Doman’s note of her experience reading the book, I doubt I will ever neglect the importance of grief, solace, and Ms. Rowling’s faith in the creation of Deathly Hallows specifically and the Harry Potter books in general.

Dear Sean,

I’d heard before that J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter books are a reflection on death, and that the author had suffered the loss of her own mother suddenly while working on the writing, an event which influenced the books’ subject and death. But I guess I wasn’t expecting to find the last book healing to me, having lost my son. [Read more…]

The Christian Content of Deathly Hallows (A)

Daniel Nexon: Harry Potter as Hero, Legend, and Global Commonplace

Daniel Nexon, Assistant Professor in the Government Department at Georgetown and keen observer of all phenomena political, literary, and cultural, has posted the notes from his Prophecy 2007 Featured Talk, “Harry Potter: From Hero to Global Commonplace,” up at The Duck of Minerva. The notes are worth reading in their own right — it is easily the best introduction and summary I have read of how to understand Harry Potter in traditional categories (myth, legend, folklore) as well as in the context of globalization — and especially edifying and challenging after the disappointing review of Deathly Hallows in The Times Sunday Book Review. Prof. Nexon’s grasp of both fantasy literature and of politico-cultural history and dynamics in the West make him an invaluable observer and exegete in the search to discover “Whence Potter-Mania.” For serious readers of Harry Potter, this is a “must read.”

NY Times Sunday Book Review: Surprise! Christopher Hitchens Does Not Like Deathly Hallows

Did anybody else wonder what the New York Times Sunday Book Review editorial board was thinking when they decided to ask Christopher Hitchens, world’s brashest atheist and author of God is Not Great, to review Joanne Rowling’s Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows? I don’t get it. I know he does book reviews for The Atlantic and The Times in addition to political commentary, but he doesn’t have any sympathy for the work, even where you think he might (can you say “Islamofascism”?).

You can still read the Hitchens review online today and Monday before it falls behind the NYT profitwall and I urge you to do so. You won’t be surprised that he urges readers to try Philip Pullman, public atheist, if they want a really good read….

More tomorrow, God willing, on the Literary Alchemy, Christian Content, and genius of Deathly Hallows. Stay tuned!

Potter Encyclopedias and Guidebooks: Let the Avalanche begin!

I was surfing a wonderful Political Science/International Relations weBlog that a new friend of mine makes contributions to and was startled to find quite a bit of Harry Potter commentary. I recommend you check out the pieces by Patrick Thaddeus Jackson on “What Harry Potter Inherits From Star Wars” and “Why Harry Potter Beats Football for Conversation” if discussion of the books as monomyth/legend/mythology or as cultural artifact is your sort of thing. Me? I was trying to get to Daniel Nexon’s “How Harry Potter Explains the World” at the New Republic Online but I couldn’t get past the subscriber-only blocker, doggone it. (You can read it here.)

What I was able to read that Prof. Nexon linked to, though, was an article by Scott McLemee from July in the Inside Higher Education blog called “Pottering Around.” Not much of what Mr. McLemee is of interest to serious readers of Harry Potter because he discloses with a hint of pleasure that he has not been up to reading any of the books or seeing any of the movies. He does share at least one thing you should know; the avalanche of academic papers and Big Publishing House Guidebooks to the series has begun. [Read more…]