Search Results for: Ink Black Heart

  • A Lake and Shed Reading of The Ink Black Heart (Kanreki 23)

    Time for Strike 5, the Blind Spot in John’s Cormoran Strike knowledge!

    Nick covers the front and the back of making Lake readings of Strike6 without a lot of circumspection and John talks about the eerie feeling he had while reading this book that the author was ‘having a go’ at him.

    The original post for this episode at the Hogwarts Professor Substack site comes with notes for the program. The index to the 31 Kanreki posts for easy reference to all the posts can be found here. Enjoy!

  • The Rowling Library Magazine #97: BBC Ink Black Heart, Ghost Plots, Rowling Newsletters, and Very Potter Christmas

    As I wrote yesterday, The Rowling Library Magazine for January 2025 is out and can be downloaded here. For serious readers of J. K. Rowling, it is the Christmas present you wanted; informative, ‘instructing while delighting,’ challenging, and a reminder of what a blessing TRL is to Rowling’s global fandom.

    Here are my homeopathic doses of each of this issue’s articles:

    Cover Story: ‘The Daily Prophet Newsletters — Uncovering one of the most elusive Harry Potter writings: J.K. Rowling’s Newsletters from 1998 and 1999.’ In an article I want to assume was written by Ibid, the eccentric Go-To expert and unchallenged authority on JKR textual histories, the reader is introduced to perhaps Rowling’s most elusive and curious work, the four newsletters Rowling penned in 1998 and 1999 for a short-lived Bloomsbury fan club in the UK. Surviving copies of the mailed newsletters are rare, especially as complete sets, and Rowling, Inc., has forbidden their reproduction. The author of this piece lovingly shares how s/he came to read an original set and enough of the newsletters to communicate their value without violating copyright. The sports page excerpts are a delight.

    ‘Ghost Plots.’ I expressed my frustration yesterday with this article’s lack of source citation in my ‘Rowling’s Real World Inspiration for Leda Strike: Nancy Spungen? but my having been inspired to write that post I hope points to the remarkable value of this survey of Rowling’s abandonded or re-shaped original ideas for the Hogwarts Saga. I expect it will inspire serious readers everywhere, as it did me, to follow up on an intriguing name or plot point suggesting a link to Rowling’s ‘Lake,’ her post Potter efforts, or to both. It merits repeated readings in this regard and makes the absence of source citations that much more disappointing.

    Publication Announcement: ‘The Phoenix or the Flame Set for February Release — Explore the release date, essays, and insights from TRL Books’ newest look at the original outline for The Order of the Phoenix.’ I wrote a chapter for this new Rowling Library (TRL) anthology and enjoyed every minute of my exchanges with The Phoenix or the Flame’s editor and the publisher, but I confess to not having an appreciation of its depths and breadth until reading this brief piece in January’s magazine. I can say as a relative insider that the textual history provided in the book of Rowling’s outline of the fifth Harry Potter novel is worth to Potter Pundits whatever they’re charging for the essay collection and I’ll admit to being delighted for the opportunity to write up at last my thoughts about the Department of Mysteries adventure’s chiastic structure, a jewel box for those sensitive to Rowling’s artistry and meaning. I’m excited by next month’s publication of The Phoenix and the Flame and I’m grateful to this article for re-igniting that flame of interest.

    Media Review: ‘A Heart Too Big for the Screen — The BBC’s bold attempt at bringing Robert Galbraith’s The Ink Black Heart to Life.’ TRL’s anonymous reviewer congratulated the screenplay writer for his adaptation of Galbraith’s Strike 6 and tipped the hat to the principal actor and actress, but noted with kindness the near impossibility of adapting this novel so that its power was communicated into an alien medium. Really, Ink Black Heart has been Rowling-Galbraith’s most challenging book to read due to its extensive use of simultaneous online chatter threads and, as hard as it was to convey that internet experience in codex, the jump to screened images alone was virtually impossible. [I thought of the conversation that was supposed to have been had between the translator of Marx’ Philosophical Manuscripts of 1848 into English from the German with its author, in which he complained of the difficulty in moving from one language to another with this book. Marx is said to have shrugged and replied, “The ideas didn’t translate easily into German, either.”] An excellent review that actually made me more interested in seeing the adaptation than I had been.

    Lead Article: ‘Why Christmas to Me is J. K. Rowling’s Old Website.’ This was far and away my favorite piece in this month’s magazine, an article that touched me as it might few others. First, it provides an inside-look at the remarkable person behind the curtain that makes TRL happen, Patricio Tarantino. I communicate with him regularly and my debts to him for the resources and tools he has created for Rowling readers grow ever deeper in depth. Yet I know very little about him, really, outside of his sterling character and fine judgment. This autobiographical episode was, consequently, a revelation on several levels and much appreciated.

    Second, tonight is Christmas Eve to Orthodox Christians and I have experienced reading (and re-reading) this article, delayed from December when the great majority of TRL readers were preparing for their Nativity celebrations, as something of a personal present under my family’s tree, delivered by TRL House Elves dispatched from Buenos Aires.

    Thank you, Mr Tarantino, for this gift and for all that you and the magazine contributors give to Rowling’s global fandom in these magazines!

  • Ink Black Heart BBC Adaptation – Episode 4 Review

    Episode 4 opens quite literally with a bang… Sarah, not knowing what was coming, was literally shocked. “You can’t go in there. Half the ceiling has come down” said Strike. A further crash. “There goes the rest of it” says the stalwart, but shaken Pat.

    The Jago Ross subplot is progressed this time by Robin rather than Midge rushing to his daughter rescue and judo throwing the ghastly Ross to get away.

    Adaptations necessarily leave out much of our best loved dialogue. When my favourite line from the book was used, I had to fight the urge to rewind and play it again. Robin and Cormoran are having their final interview with Vernon Dursley… sorry.. Grant Ledwell. “Might need a bit of good cop / bad cop.” said Strike. “How bad do you want me to be?” Robin replied.

    From a book reader’s point of view, this season delivered in spades with the pacing and character introductions improving as the series progressed. This must have been the most challenging of the series so far, and could easily have descended into a confusing mess. The story climax was tense and exciting, but the clue progression did not make Sarah feel cheated that the villain was only briefly seen in episode 1. We both agree that the acting, particularly from Tom and Holliday was first rate, with the closing scenes moving both of us very much.

    The HBO series is due to air January 23rd, in the mean time merry Christmas one and all!

  • Ink Black Heart BBC Adaptation – Episode 3 Review

    Episode 3 opens with Barclay alive, hooray! and ambushing the ambusher. The vile Phillip Ormond is in custody geting his just deserts meanwhile Anomie is inviting all to Comic-Con. When asked to look for costumes Pat, who plays brilliantly asks – “Are we doing Kids parties now?”

    Vernon Dursley… sorry… Grant Ledwell is interviewed in Denmark Street and makes the key mistake, moving from singular to plural when talking of the letters buried with Edie. Sarah, who has not read the books, picked up on this immediately, proving her far better at solving detective fiction than I will ever be!

    Tom Burke is satisfyingly comic in his Darth Vader outfit, and fandom leader Yasmin Weatherhead is very recognisable both from the book and heady days of Potter-mania. Episode three ends with the death of Vikas. A lot has happened in less than an hour, but with clever pacing, this never seems confusing and there is a definite feeling that progress is being made. Join me tomorrow for the conclusion!

  • Ink Black Heart BBC Adaptation – Episode 2 Review

    This episode kicks off with Robin, in her Jessica Robins persona, visiting Highgate Cemetery and meeting up with Pez. This is a visual treat for those of us who haven’t yet been able to visit and remains my visual cue for the book.

    The characters we love to hate! A reintroduction of Charlotte and her messy divorce from Jago, and the deliciously awful Inigo Upcott. It is clear at this point (when Charlotte tipped Robin to Madeline’s existence, and similarity to Robin) that Madeline will not be making an appearance outside of voice calls and text messages.

    To create a thrilling episode 2 cliffhanger, we have Barclay tailing Phillip Ormond and discovering his disposal of Edie Ledwell’s phone. Somehow Ormond discovers his tail, and the episode ends with Barclay being run off the road! I couldn’t help but grumble to Sarah “well that didn’t happen in the books…”, but it definitely added sufficient tension to make sure she wanted to see the next episode.