Rowling’s Pregnancy Traps: How Many?

I’m writing up a Substack post on the ‘pregnancy trap’ plot points and characters in the work of J. K. Rowling, from Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone to last year’s Running Grave. It’s part of the Fourth Generation ‘Rowling Studies’ effort at HogwartsProfessor to begin looking at her work from a mountain top or macroscopic view across series and individual novels, screenplays, and the one play script rather than the microscopic examination of the latest work and consequent speculating about the next coming thing.

A key part of that work is to identify plot point ‘golden threads’ in addition to the Shed artistic elements I have labored to draw out through the years (psychomachia, alchemy, chiasmus, mythology, etc.). Perhaps the most curious of these is the ‘pregnancy trap’ in which a man or woman, usually a woman, attempts to force his or her partner into a relationship commitment, usually marriage, by either becoming pregnant (if male, all but insuring that the female partner becomes pregnant) or offering oneself as a sex object.

The first step in identifying and discussing a golden thread,’ a plot point found in many of Rowling’s work and at the heart of the story involved, is to run through the oeuvre or opera omnia to date and check to see if the point is indeed prevalent — and, perhaps as important, that all the instances have been found. My working list for ‘pregnancy traps’ in Rowling’s work include these ten instances — and I ask for your help in critiquing this list and letting me know of others that I in my haste have overlooked:  

In roughly chronological order, then, here are my top ten pregnancy traps in the work of J. K. Rowling.

  1. Merope Gaunt
  2. Krystall Weedon
  3. Kay Bawden
  4. Bellatrix Lestrange (Cursed Child)
  5. Leda Strike (and Jeff Whittaker?)
  6. Charlotte Campbell
  7. Sarah Shadlock
  8. Ornella Serafin
  9. Janice Beattie
  10. Belinda Watkins

I wanted to add Romilda Vane for the Love Potion she tries to slip Harry Potter in Half Blood Prince via Gillywater and chocolates but realized I’d have to add Molly Weasley, another Amortentia brewer, if I stretched ‘pregnancy trap’ to include all entrapments.

I anticipate objections to Kay Bawden, Bellatrix Lestrange, and Charlotte Campbell being on the list, perhaps even Leda Strike, all of which I will discuss in my Substack piece. That piece will also include ‘Lake’ speculation about the crisis in Rowling’s life that makes this plot point something akin to a child without parents in Dickens or a poisoner in Agatha Christie’s murder mysteries. Note how many there are in the Strike-Ellacott series — more than half the list.

For now, though, I’m most interested in help identifying the pregnancy trappers, male and female, I have overlooked. Thank you in advance for sharing your finds in the comment boxes below!

 

Comments

  1. Although not confirmed, Ryan Murphy might deserve an honorable mention. Also, a pregnancy trap doesn’t have to be diabolical, to be a trap does it? If Robin is indeed not sterile, but impregnated by Murphy after months of forcibly missing birth control pills, she would still be trapped by pregnancy and facing a decision.

Speak Your Mind

*