Skip to content
  • Home
  • John Granger — “The Dean of Harry Potter Scholars”
  • HogPro AuthorsExpand
    • Nick Jeffery
    • Elizabeth Baird Hardy
  • HogPro Bookstore
  • Contact
Site Banner
Site Banner
  • Chaos Walking: No ‘Monsters of Men’ Predictions

    ByJohn September 27, 2010August 3, 2023
    4 Comments

    Well, here is a busted play.

    I was all pumped for discussion and predictions of the first two books in the Chaos Walking trilogy before the finale is published tomorrow — but there was no hold on the release of the third book, Monsters of Men, and it has been thoroughly reviewed with most plot points that would have been subject to speculation now part of the public record. And why not? The book has been available in hardcover and paperback in the UK since 3 May of this year.

    Which status quo calls for a HogwartsProfessor Book Club change of plans! Here are the changes: Read More “Chaos Walking: No ‘Monsters of Men’ Predictions”

  • Reading Ideas For Ness’ The Act and the Answer Five Days Until Chaos Walking Trilogy Finale

    ByJohn September 23, 2010September 23, 2010
    3 Comments

    The first book we will be reading in the Hogwarts Professor Book Club is Patrick Ness’ Monsters of Men, which will be published on 28 September. The thing is that Monsters is not a stand alone work; it’s the final novel in Mr. Ness’ Chaos Walking trilogy. If you haven’t read the first two Chaos books, The Knife of Never Letting Go and The Ask and The Answer, then you have a bunch of great reading to do in the next five days. No joke, get to it! In terms of the “parable fiction” I described earlier this week as the fruit of the Harry Potter tree, Patrick Ness’ Chaos Walking is an allegorical challenge while being a great read.

    Last week I wrote out five “reading ideas” for Knife of Never Letting Go. My job today is to provide the same sort of  questions and thoughts for your reflection on your first or second trip through the second book, The Ask and the Answer, ideas that will simultaneously encourage you to make return trips to the book while not spoiling firsttimers’ experience of the story. In the next few days before Monsters of Men‘s publication, I’ll put up some speculative notes about the last book that will assume you’ve read Knife and The Ask.

    Here are my first five ideas to spur your thinking: Read More “Reading Ideas For Ness’ The Act and the Answer Five Days Until Chaos Walking Trilogy Finale”

  • Reading Ideas: The Knife of Never Letting Go

    ByJohn September 14, 2010September 14, 2010
    13 Comments

    The first book we will be reading in the Hogwarts Professor Book Club is Patrick Ness’ Monsters of Men, which will be published on 28 September. The thing is that Monsters is not a stand alone work; it’s the final novel in Mr. Ness’ Chaos Walking trilogy. If you haven’t read the first two book, The Knife of Never Letting Go and The Ask and The Answer, then you have a bunch of great reading to do in the next two weeks.

    The bad news is “time is short!” The good news is that that’s the only bad news; the novels are wonderfully well written, challenging, and promise a huge pay-off ( a Monster pay-off?) in the series finale. My job this week and next is to provide “reading ideas,” questions and thoughts for your reflection on your first or second trip through the first and second books, ideas to foster return trips to the book that are spoiler free. In the days just prior to Monsters of Men‘s publication, I’ll put up some speculative notes about the last book that will assume you’ve read Knife and The Ask.

    Here are my first five ideas to spur your thinking:

    Read More “Reading Ideas: The Knife of Never Letting Go”

Page navigation

Previous PagePrevious 1 2

Hogwarts Professor Pillar Posts

Keys to Understanding J. K. Rowling’s Novels and Screenplays

  • Pillar Post Updates
  • Ink Black Heart Discussion
  • Updated: Ring Composition Pillar Post
  • Parallel Series Idea
  • Psychomachia
  • Cormoran Strike: Troubled Blood
  • The 'Why' and 'How to' of Pillar Posts
  • Individual Rowling Works
  • Keys For Interpretation
  • Movie Reviews
  • J.K. Rowling Miscellany
  • Mailbag: Q&A
  • Authors NOT J.K Rowling (Hunger Games, etc.)
  • Book Reviews/Author Interviews
  • Mugglenet Podcasts
Search

Recent Conversation

  • AG on Rowling’s Admitted Literary Influences
  • Dr. K. on Guest Post: Christmas Gift List #4 — Forgotten Inkling: The Writings and Legacy of Roger Lancelyn Green
  • Jen on Rowling Writes “Really Sad Chapter;” Who Dies in Sleep Tight Evangeline?
  • John on Rowling Writes “Really Sad Chapter;” Who Dies in Sleep Tight Evangeline?
  • Jen on Rowling Writes “Really Sad Chapter;” Who Dies in Sleep Tight Evangeline?

Categories

Blogroll

  • Accio-Quote.org
  • The Rowling Library

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

© 2026 Hogwarts Professor

  • Home
  • John Granger — “The Dean of Harry Potter Scholars”
  • HogPro Authors
    • Nick Jeffery
    • Elizabeth Baird Hardy
  • HogPro Bookstore
  • Contact