Strike Fandom Film Montage: ‘Still Life’

I’m not a big fan of the teevee adaptation of the Cormoran Strike novels, but lovely films like this ‘Still Life’ by “iriis” help me understand why I am an extreme outlier among Serious Strikers in this regard. Not only does it highlight the wonderful actors playing Robin and Cormoran, but the skillful editing and background music make for a captivating montage, from the couple’s first meeting to a shot of the post American Bar office scene in the dark.

In the comment boxes below, please let me know your favorite YouTube video artists in the Strike fandom and what you think is their best work. And has anyone attempted to film scenes from the books on their own, productions apart from the Bronte Studio versions, akin to what Harry Potter fandom has done through the years?

Evan Willis- Strike Series Ranking

Continuing our series of Hogwarts Professor staff posts ranking the Strike books, I’ll be adding my thoughts to the mix. (After which, I will be interestedly reading through everybody else’s posts, eager to hear what they thought and how they evaluated the texts!)

My method here will be informed by my general tendencies when reading. I struggle with texts if they are considered by themselves alone, independent of other texts. The more I can practice what Mortimer Adler called Syntopical reading, reading texts together in each other’s light, the better I will enjoy and gain from any given book. I will, therefore, tend to rank texts higher when they play a pivotal role narratively in a series, or when the motifs or structure of a text is well illumined by or illuminating of other texts, or most generally when they reward Syntopical reading. The degree to which a book is fundamentally about how one reads, as in the common text-within-a-text of Rowling’s writing, also act favorably in my evaluation. This is not the only standard applied, of course, but in evaluating these books this aspect came up most frequently. In no small part, what follows is just the degree of enjoyment I had while reading each of them, such that the justifications below might not be as airtight as they could be. Ranking follows after the jump, starting from last place and continuing to first.

[Read more…]

The Witch Trials of J. K. Rowling

Yesterday (21st February) a new podcast dropped. Provocatively titled “The Witch Trials of J. K. Rowling” it is billed as “an audio documentary that examines some of the most contentious conflicts of our time through the life and career of the world’s most successful author.” The host is a remarkable lady called Megan Phelps-Roper, an ex-member of the Westboro Baptist Church. Remarkable not least because she is an example of someone who changed their mind via the medium of social media. Join me after the jump for links to the episodes, and a few of the nuggets that I’ve found.

[Read more…]

The Running Grave – Fandom Sleuthing Roundup

On the 17th of January J. K. Rowling tweeted a picture- the completed manuscript copy of the seventh instalment in the Strike series.

Quickly seeing that type from the page below was visible The Rowling Library posted a contrast enhanced image that showed the opening lines from Dylan Thomas’ poem When Like a Running Grave and a passage from The I Ching.

The Epigraphs

Here at Hogwarts Professor, close reader Percy Lin identified the I Ching passage as the comment of Wenyan Zhuan (文言傳, “Commentary on the Words”) on Hexagram 2  (坤 kūn, “Field”): “其所由来者渐矣。由辨之不早辨也”

It took a long time for things to go so far. It came about because things that should have been stopped were not stopped soon enough.

We are fortunate to have more than one I Ching irregular here at HogPro with close reader Luis E Andrade adding their analysis:

Curiously, the Wenyan Zhuan, the so called Seventh Wing of the Yijing, and not part of the core text of the Zhouyi but part of Han Dynasty exegesis added when it was canonized as one of the five Confucian Classics to become the “Yijing” (易經), only extends to the first two hexagrams in the received, and so called, King Wen sequence. The commentary goes on at length for the first hexagram but it is much shorter for the second, 坤, translated as The Receptive by Wilhelm/Baynes. In particular, the quote used, refers to the portion dedicated to comment the first line of H2 and translated as “When there is hoarfrost underfoot, solid ice is not far off.” Using that as reference, you can see why the comment talks about events that should have been dealt with in time but have run out of their control by neglecting to do so.

The Running Grave Publication Date

This is not the first time that Rowling has tweeted a completed manuscript on Twitter. On 23trd March 2018 she announced that Lethal White was completed. Perhaps because of a noted lifelong struggle with printers, this was illustrated with a USB memory stick. Lethal White was published on the 18th September 2018. On 25th January 2020 Rowling posted a picture of the, as yet unnamed, Troubled Blood manuscript. Troubled Blood was published on 15th September 2020. No manuscript tweet for Ink Black Heart, but she tweeted that it was finished on 3rd December 2021. Ink Black Heart was published on 30th August 2022.

For most recent Strike novels we have a time between completion and publication ranging from 179 days for Lethal White and 270 days for The Ink Black Heart. For The Running Grave, that means a publication date between 15th July and 14th October.

Here’s hoping for an early Summer release!

“Women Who Swap HyperCareer for Family at 30 Are Rule Not Exception”

Rowling-Galbraith and Jordan Peterson seem to have made the same observations about women celebrating their 30th birthdays.

It appears, though, that Robin is resisting the possibility of cutting back her vocational commitment as full-time private detective. Or is that a Troubled Blood take-away, not Ink-Black Heart‘s conclusion?