Sunrise on the Reaping Placeholder 8: ‘Lenore’ and ‘Raven’ as Story Templates

One of the first tasks for Hunger Games serious readers after finishing their first trips through Sunrise on the Reaping will be to find a copy of Edgar Allen Poe‘s ‘Lenore‘ and ‘The Raven‘ and see how much they serve together as a story template for Lenore Dove and her true love, Haymitch Abernathy. Does it parallel how Collins used Wordsworth’s ‘Lucy Gray’ in Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes?

The first task, if you’re like me and it has been some time since you read Poe’s poems in a sophomore ‘Survey of Literature’ course (closer to a half-century in the past for me than a quarter), is to distinguish the meteoric American genius’ two poems. Both feature a lost love, a Lenore who died as a beautiful young woman who is lamented by a narrator haunted by her memory. The namesake poem ‘Lenore,’ however, is only four stanzas in length and is not the poem that Haymitch memorizes for Miss Dove’s birthday. That is the much longer, much, much more famous (can you say ‘NFL football franchise name famous‘?), and more mind-catching (Ear worm!) ‘The Raven.’

I suspect (and will eventually explore) that this poem serves a three-fold purpose in Collins’ second prequel:

  • It’s the story template, i.e., Lenore Dove becomes the Lenore of ‘The Raven’ and he akin to the narrator of that poem;
  • It’s Collins’ embedded statement about the importance of story form and symbolism in her writing per Poe’s Philosophy of Composition and his idea of Unity of Effect; and
  • Poe’s thought about the estranging, shocking effects of horror in a story to make as profound and transformative or cathartic impression upon a reader is the foundation principle of Collins’ Underlander and Hunger Games living nightmares.

Which is quite the burden to place on an embedded poem, I know. I hope readers will share all the references to Poe, his poetry and short stories, they found in Sunrise. Have at it!

 

Sunrise on the Reaping Placeholder 4: Parallels Between Katniss and Haymitch

Day 2 of Sunrise on the Reaping Conversation!

I’m halfway through the second Hunger Games prequel (late delivery of the book and a closing shift at work meant I couldn’t begin reading the actual codex copy until 10:30 last night) and, so far, so great. I hope your reading has Exceeded Expectations as much as mine has despite having some very high expectations, indeed.

In this fourth Placeholder post, a place for discussion of specific ideas while we read or after our first reading (Release the Spoilers!), let’s talk about the ways that Haymitch’s first trip to the Capitol parallels Katniss Everdeen’s odyssey in agony during The Hunger Games (book one in the series). I summarized what we learned from the ‘Sneak Peeks’ in my Predictions post Monday this way:

both of the Scholastic ‘Sneak Peeks’ were heavy in resonances with the first Hunger Games novel: the wake-up for an early morning trip to the woods on Reaping Day, a food gift from family, a note that Haymitch found the plums in the forest (he’s a forager?), the slightly off relationship with the widow-mother, the beloved younger sibling, the borderline clandestine meeting with a dear friend of the opposite sex and conversation on the edge of argument about the Reaping, Buttercup the cat and Lenore’s geese not being friends of our heroine and hero.

There are a bunch more, of course, in the actual book. Please share your list and your first thoughts about why you think Collins is writing this prequel as the earlier echo of the later series.

Sunrise on the Reaping Placeholder Posts:

1: First Impressions — Delight or Dismay?

2. The Epigraphs from Orwell, Blake, and Hume

3. Collins’ Signature Story Structure

4. Katniss-Haymitch Parallels (Books 1 and 5)

5. Breaks with Catching Fire Version of Quarter Quell

6. Catching Fire Cast of Characters, Echoes

Sunrise on the Reaping Placeholder 5: The Sanitized Quarter Quell Propaganda

Day 2 of Sunrise on the Reaping Conversation!

One of the head scratcher mysteries about Sunrise on the Reaping that I returned to repeatedly in the run-up to yesterday’s publication of the second Hunger Games prequel was just how much of the story we had already been given. (See my ‘Everything We Know from the First Four Hunger Games Novels‘ for a full review of what we’d been told about Haymitch Abernathy’s Quarter Quell.) I marveled that Collins was writing a novel whose substance and ending she had already revealed.

It turns out that what we were told wasn’t actually the case, something that I might have guessed when the author saidrepeatedly that the book will be about the propaganda pushers’ power to shape a narrative. From the Reaping day in District 12 forward, the actual events and the official, re-packaged version for the public and for the historical record have little to nothing in common except the cast of characters.

For discussion in the comment thread below, then, two topics: first, let’s list all the things we learned (sic) in, say Catching Fire’s Quarter Quell video tape that Peeta and Katniss naively watch on the train to the Capitol, and what Sunrise reveals was actually the case (or times the events of Sunrise are immediately re-made) and, then, some speculation about where Collins is going with this. is it only an invitation to Young Adult readers to a Humean skepticism about all public messaging as necessarily sanitized versions of the truth to serve the regime power holders or is it something more?

Sunrise on the Reaping Placeholder Posts:

1: First Impressions — Delight or Dismay?

2. The Epigraphs from Orwell, Blake, and Hume

3. Collins’ Signature Story Structure

4. Katniss-Haymitch Parallels (Books 1 and 5)

5. Breaks with Catching Fire Version of Quarter Quell

6. Catching Fire Cast of Characters, Echoes

Sunrise on the Reaping Placeholder 6: The Catching Fire Cast of Characters

Day 2 of Sunrise on the Reaping Conversation!

I started off today’s three Placeholder Posts with one for Day of Publication readers to share all the parallels they saw between the second Hunger Games prequel and first novel in the series, The Hunger Games. Katniss’s first trip to the Capitol and Haymitch’s years earlier seem to have a whole lot in common, eerily so.

The second Placeholder post today invited readers to re-visit Catching Fire‘s Quarter Quell video that Peeta and Katniss watch on their way to the Capitol for the second Games in as many years to spot all the differences between what we were told happened in Haymitch’s first Games and what we learn in Sunrise actually happened.

Today’s third Post, as you might expect, is a place for Sunrise readers to share the many echoes they hear in the second prequel of the second and third Hunger Games novels, Catching Fire and Mockingjay. It turns out Haymitch Abernathy met most of his friends that Katniss and Peeta meet in the Third Quarter Quell arena on his first trip to the Capitol. Surprise!

Please share your list of Catching Fire and Mockingjay’s cast of characters that gave you an ‘Oh, My!’ thrill of recognition in Sunrise at the Reaping and your first thoughts about the Pearl Plot’s likelihood, that Haymitch is the Master Gamesmaker of the Mockingjay Revolution

More tomorrow!

Sunrise on the Reaping Placeholder Posts:

1: First Impressions — Delight or Dismay?

2. The Epigraphs from Orwell, Blake, and Hume

3. Collins’ Signature Story Structure

4. Katniss-Haymitch Parallels (Books 1 and 5)

5. Breaks with Catching Fire Version of Quarter Quell

6. Catching Fire Cast of Characters, Echoes

Sunrise on the Reaping Placeholder 1: First Impressions – Delight or Dismay?

Publication Day at last!

Whether you purchased your copy of Sunrise at a Midnight Madness party last night or it arrived just after sunrise today, I assume that like me you’ll be listening to or reading the second Hunger Games prequel novel for a day or two.

Our custom here in the week following new releases of long anticipated books is to post Placeholder discussion pieces at which rapid readers can share their first thoughts on specific subjects. I hope to be putting up several of these the first few days before offering my first thoughts on Haymitch’s adventure in the Quarter Quell and Coriolanus Snow’s political rise.

The first of these Placeholders is a natural one — what were your first thoughts on reading Suzanne Collins’ latest? Did it meet your high bar standard and expectations for a Panem novel or were you disappointed? Let us know in the comment boxes below!

All these discussions, of course, will be chock full of spoilers and should be avoided if you don’t want to learn in advance more of the story than the great deal having already been revealed in the previous four Hunger Games pieces. Caveat lector!

Sunrise on the Reaping Placeholder Posts:

1: First Impressions — Delight or Dismay?

2. The Epigraphs from Orwell, Blake, and Hume

3. Collins’ Signature Story Structure