Deathly Hallows (Part 1): A Reader’s Movie Notes

I really struggle with writing movie reviews.

I don’t know about you, but I roll my eyeballs at film criticism written by serious book readers in which the reviewer just doesn’t get beyond a throw-away acknowledgment that screened images and printed text are different media so the stories are necessarily different. Reading all the changes made in the jump from page to celluloid, be it in the Potter and Twilight franchises or in Narnia and Middle Earth, especially when these changes are noted with disapproval, disappointment, and a dismissive dismay at what the film-going reader experiences as something like heresy or sacrilege, leaves me marveling that anyone in the 21st Century still doesn’t understand that the movie experience is not and cannot be the reader’s experience of story. (Prof. Baird Hardy, of course, gets it just right.)

[Read more…]

‘Ring Composition’ and Pundits’ ‘Smart Talk’ Highlight HogPro Deathly Hallows Speaking Tour

If this is Veterans Day, I must have the day off! I am home for a few days break in the ‘Deathly Hallows (Part 1) Speaking Tour’ and, while I am loving the home cooked food and sleeping in my own bed, I can honestly report that all the places I have spoken in the last three weeks – from Augustana College on the Mississippi River to Church of the Holy Cross above the Chesapeake Bay, from the cool Emmanuel Community United Methodist Church  in Wisconsin in the north to the wonderfully warm University of South Carolina — have all been so welcoming and kind that I didn’t want to leave for the next date. I’ll write a proper ‘thank you’ with stories from the tour when it’s over, but, until then, here are two observations as a welcome to newcomers and a note to old friends I’m neglecting…

(1) I’ve covered close to 5,000 miles by plane and car and spoken at great schools and at beautiful churches, a library, even an independent Book Store. Everywhere I’ve talked and no matter what the subject at hand was on a given night, the buzz at evening’s end was about Ms. Rowling’s writing in rings, both as the structure of her seven story cycle and as her template for the chapters of each book. The reason I’m traveling so much is because of the upcoming Deathly Hallows (Part 1) Warner Bros movie release and the fact that I’m the only person to have written an entire book on the artistry and meaning of Hallows, namely The Deathly Hallows Lectures. What has folks talking, though, isn’t the alchemy of the finale, the eyeball symbolism, or Christian content of Harry’s victory over death and the Dark Lord at King’s Cross, it’s the heretofore unrecognized traditional template for storytelling that Ms. Rowling used for the series and every novel in it. I have written up my talk on this subject with all the necessary charts and images that can be downloaded here or purchased as a short book; overlook the many typos please — and prepare to have the way you look at the world’s best selling books changed forever.

(2) Because I was as surprised and delighted as any Harry Potter reader to discover that there was anything as significant as the stories’ fundamental structure left to be revealed more than three years after Deathly Hallows’ publication,  I was not surprised that this topic became the focus of my conversation with audiences on the current tour. What has surprised me is how many people listen to the Leaky Cauldron’s ‘PotterCast’ and the ‘Potter Pundits’ segment Travis Prinzi, James Thomas, and I do on that program. It seems every talk I have given has been followed by at least one person referencing the program during questions or telling me during ‘Gilderoy Time’ (book autographing exchanges) that they love the Pundits and our new book, Harry Potter Smart Talk. Smart Talk has six new essays from the three Pundits as well as transcripts from our most popular shows, reading which collection Melissa Anelli wrote in her introduction to the book is like finding “the Ivory Tower in Hagrid’s Hut.” As one reviewer wrote,

The formal essays by the individual pundits are excellent in the same way [as their podcast conversations are]. They are fascinatingly informative and profoundly probing, but the writing style is lively and anything but dry. … and these guys really know their stuff – not just what they bring from their respective academic fields, but also just about every detail there is to know from the Potter books.

I’m speaking in Marion, Ohio, and Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, next week (details below the jump) and I look forward to meeting you there! My thanks to everyone I’ve spoken and stayed with on the tour thus far for their enthusiasm and their kindness to me — and my thanks to readers here for their patience with me during these travels and the big gaps between posts.

[Read more…]

Daniel Radcliffe’s ‘Deathly Hallows’ Question: “Why Doesn’t Harry Turn Into Somebody Else?”

How about a Harry Potter Discussion Point for a change? Something about Deathly Hallows —

Here’s a question posed by Daniel Radcliffe from the set of the last movie being filmed. The Empire magazine reporter is talking about the great opening scene shot where there are seven Harry Potters, all of whom, of course, are played by Daniel Radcliffe; through the magic of 21st century movie cameras, the escape from Privet Drive’s Polyjuice moment only took 95 takes to get right.

Dan’s Question is something like “Why did the Order of the Phoenix bother with this involved charade?”

[Read more…]

The Trailer Madness Begins!

Check out the brand new Deathly Hallows teaser trailer above! After the MTV tease was yanked, maybe this one will stick around until the next, more tempting morsel.

Thoughts? Criticism? Shrieks of horror or delight? What do you think of seeing bits from both halves, including the big finale? The dragon is white — hurrah! Personally, I’ll be scouring the stores to get a smart suit like Hermione appears to be sporting this time around. You?

Great Plotting Blunders #1: Regulus Black

One complaint I have heard about Hogwarts Professor is that I don’t post many items that are critical of Ms. Rowling’s writing. I think that’s fair criticism. My job for the last seven years has been to explain to folks who believe the writing is trash and the books “slop” how the books succeed, which is to say, how Ms. Rowling’s artistry and meaning are responsible for Potter Mania.

I find conversations like this one at The Hog’s Head about the lack of grieving time for Harry, in which readers discuss how this isn’t that much of a problem, more interesting than ones where folks look down their noses at “obvious failings” in plot and characterization.

But there are some problems worth discussing. And we should talk about them here. Because I’m not very good at this, though, I will hand the blog reins today to two Potter Experts from the Debt Coast, Wendy and the Red Hen. Their subject: the critical and failed plot points of Regulus Black’s sacrificial death and the Locket Horcrux. [Read more…]