Allegiant 2: Predictions Scorecard

I asked Dr. Louise Freeman, our resident Divergent authority, to share her predictions last week and she wrote me to say that what she’d already written would suffice. In bullet point form, her predictions were:

  • Marcus redeemed and dead,
  • Caleb probably just dead,
  • Pit flooded and
  • Tris leading a group of Dauntless back up the Hancock tower.

That’s about 50%, I’d say, depending on how you score Tris’ trip up the Tower. If you think that’s bad forecasting, (a) that’s very good for a HogwartsProfessor and (b) we specialize in exegesis, not tea leave reading. Read Prof Freeman’s brilliant A Dip in the OCEAN: Divergent Factions and the Big Five Personality Factors and A Dip in the OCEAN II: Double Dipping Dauntless: Can the neurotic be brave? for more along those lines!

In her alchemical predictions about the Rubedo elements to look for in Allegiant, Christine Wesley forecast so many details of the finale that I’m obliged to urge you to follow the link! No bullet point list could do it justice. I hope Christine will share her own scoring of her prediction in her hermetic follow-up to these predictions.

Her biggest hit, I think, was her writing that there would be a Marcus-Johanna alliance and her biggest miss was her Serum Theory of what caused the Chicago Experiment in Faction Living. I’m not sure I agree with the readers who wrote on the day of release that they wished Christine had written the ending because they were so disappointed in Allegiant and thought the Rubedo described here would have been more interesting, but I share their admiration for the alchemical alternative.

I didn’t make predictions except for a playful listing of possibilities of why there was a Five Faction World in the first place:

We are in the last months before Allegiant is published, which publication will reveal at last the secrets of the post-apocalypse Divergent psycho-drama theme park in Chicago.

Is it a mad scientist turned voyeur experiment for broadcasting a la The Truman Show? Are Tris and Tobias starring in another re-make of Special Service?

An Art Farm for human beings set up by aliens akin to King’s Under the Dome?

Or is this something like the Chicago ‘Projects,’ urban renewal and political correctness become self-perpetuating nightmare? Is Divergent something of a psychologist’s Cabrini Green?

I think that last one is close to a bulls eye strike and the first one came to mind a few times when we sat with those out at O’hare airport monitoring life in the Factions Project. Just sayin.’

Please share your thoughts in the comment boxes below, especially if you know of a Divergent expert who guessed, I mean, predicted a good deal of what we saw in Allegiant — without, that is, having procured a copy in advance…

Allegiant 1: Delighted or Disappointed?

I was disappointed that my favorite local book store didn’t have a copy of Allegiant on Tuesday afternoon when I biked over to Full Circle to pick up the finale on the day of publication. They called later in the day to say “the afternoon truck” had brought it to Oklahoma City.

I was delighted, consequently, to purchase it the next day after work — and to spend the rest of the afternoon and evening, well past my bed time, reading Veronica Roth’s surprising conclusion to her Divergent trilogy.

In keeping with our HogPro custom of throwing up (ahem) twenty or more threads after the arrival of a much anticipated novel, let the fun begin here with you comments about your delight and/or disappointment with Allegiant. Tell us how the concluding novel met or failed to meet your expectations, what you loved, what you hated, what you wished had happened, what happened that knocked you off your tuffet.

And, then, of course, please share your thoughts after the other 19 or so threads… Feel free to talk openly about the book’s plot points and twists; if you’re reading this, it’s upon you to have read the book first or to forgo complaints about “having been spoiled.”

MuggleNet Academia: Harry Potter and the Brotherly Love Cup

I join MuggleNet’s Keith Hawk for conversation with Profs Karen Wendling and Patrick McCauley about how Chestnut Hill College‘s Interdisciplinary Honors Program used Harry Potter to explore the coming-of-age novel and the hero’s journey. And how the town of Chestnut Hill celebrates the Hogwarts Saga every year in conjunction with the College and a Quid-Atlantic Quidditch Tournament of university teams and all-comers.

If you enjoyed the ‘Father Symbolism in Prisoner‘ guest post by Prof McCauley, you’ll love this podCast. The folks at Chestnut Hill are taking the lead in shaping what the future of serious reading in fandom will look like — plenty of fun without the Theme Park excess (and pusillanimous postmodern political partisanship…) and the heart of it all is collegial discussion of literary artistry, meaning, and experience. I cannot get to Philadelphia this weekend but I’m already planning to travel to next year’s Harry Potter Conference and Festival at Chestnut Hill. See you there?


[Read more…]

Guest Post: Professor Patrick McCauley, Chestnut Hill College, ‘The Symbol of the Father in Prisoner of Azkaban’

Dr. Patrick McCauley is Assistant Professor of Religious Studies at Chestnut Hill College just outside Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. I spoke with him and his colleague Professor Karen Wendling last night about the course they have taught in Chestnut Hill’s innovative Interdisciplinary Honors Program and about papers each presented at last year’s academic conference. It was a conversation you can hear at MuggleNet Academia this week, and, if I say so myself, it’s a podcast you’ll enjoy. Prof McCauley shared his thinking about ‘The Symbol of the Father in Prisoner of Azkaban,’ which was fascinating even in thumbnail vignette. I asked his permission to share his 10 minute lecture notes here so you could also benefit from his more ordered presentation. Enjoy!

October 26, 2012 – Harry Potter Conference – Chestnut Hill College

“The Symbol of the Father in the Prisoner of Azkaban”­

It can often be difficult to determine our own most excellent or fulfilling aspiration.  Paul Tillich discusses the necessity of orienting symbols within the search for our most appropriate individual purpose.  Joseph Campbell focuses in on the specific symbol of the Father as inspiring guide toward authentic identity and personal mission.  J. K. Rowling offers a sophisticated glimpse into the nature of this empowering symbol in The Prisoner of Azkaban.  Rowling effectively and purposely brings the external and internal image of the Father into productive tension.  This talk will attempt to reveal that belief in the literal existence of the Father figure may perform an indispensable role within the overall dynamic of symbolic orientation and inspiration.

[Read more…]

Chestnut Hill Harry Potter Festival: Quidditch, Pub Crawl, Etc.

I love Oklahoma City, but for Potter Punditry I confess to missing Philadelphia. Not only does the City of Brotherly Love have the PotterDelphia Meet-Up group, but it boasts the annual Chestnut Hill Harry Potter Festival. Chestnut Hill College has a full blown Quidditch Tournament as well as an Academic Conference and the village of Chestnut Hill gets into the act with a full two day schedule of Harry Potter events.

The Town-Gown Festival is Friday and Saturday 18-19 October. You can read about it here, here, and here. The Academic Conference at the college  is 18 October from 3-5 pm and you can learn about their speakers and subjects here. As you can tell from the video above, it’s a blast.

PotterDelphians, please send us a report!