Guest Post: The Symbolic Identity of Alma Coin

As John Granger and I get our brooms polished up to race down to Orlando and Leaky-Con, we’re delighted to showcase this lovely guest post from Nicole Olson, who wanted to share her fascinating insights on the chracter of Alma Coin in the Hunger Games. Thanks, Nicole!

First of all, I’d like to thank John Granger for giving me the opportunity to share this theory with you on Hogwarts Professor. It is largely an extension of the very insightful work articulated by John in his articles Unlocking Mockingjay, but with a narrower focus on the symbolic role of President Coin in Katniss’s apotheosis. I am not a professor, but merely another interested reader captivated by The Hunger Games and craving a deeper discussion of the ensuing symbolism. In the spirit of Hogwarts Professor, I offer this theory for your consideration and look forward to your comments and corrections.    The assassination of Alma Coin is one of the most jarring scenes in Mockingjay. It seems fairly straightforward to argue that Katniss would assassinate Coin to both avenge her sister’s death and to prevent further suffering under Coin’s rule. However, for Katniss, I believe there is a much greater significance. After all, the shooting of Coin was the final cathartic event in her spiritual journey. It is also worth noting that in the moment before releasing the arrow, her mind did not dwell on Coin’s suggestion of a Capitol Hunger Games, or the fire-bombing in the Capitol, but rather was drawn back into the allegorical Garden of Eden with President Snow. I believe Snow, Katniss, and Coin are all connected on a deeper level and Eden holds the key. [Read more…]

DH:II Countdown: More Literary Goodies from the Vaults

After our last post on the book versus movie debate, we had some great new comments on that topic, so I thought it might be fun to get some more literary conversation going with these two jewels that were down in the vault with the big blind dragon out front.  In these two posts, our intrepid Headmaster analyzes the two fascinating epigraphs for The Deathly Hallows: one from William Penn’s More Fruits of Solitude and one from the Aeschylus play The Libation Bearers. If you haven’t noticed by now, our Ms. Rowling does very little without careful thought and deliberation (and determination, and destination!).  Her epigraphs were selected with the utmost care, and their resonance through the text is powerful indeed.  Enjoy these gems, as we ruminate on two bits of text that never had a chance of making it into either section of the Deathly Hallows  movie (c’mon, you movie people, prove me wrong!). And keep those comments and suggestions coming as we head into the home stretch!

DH:II Movie Countdown–Remember when….

Now that we know the complete Harry Potter story from beginning to end, it is sometimes hard to remember just what a big part of our lives was once consumed with making predictions about how it all would end, how we spent those years between books feverishly speculating. In fact, my husband was not sure we should let our son read the whole series beginning to end, since we had to endure that dreadful interlibrum (wait between volumes). In fact, that wait has led me to since swear off beginning any series that was not yet complete (I did cheat for Hunger Games, since I started just a few months before Mockingjay).  The wait for the last film isn’t so tough, of course, as we know how it goes, but it is fun to look back at how we spent our time about four years ago. This fun post looks back at the many predictions made by scholars and readers before the release of the final volume, and includes votes and comments for the best, most accurate, and just plain wackiest pre-publication predictions.  Enjoy! And keep those suggestions coming about posts you would like to see released from the past!

DH:II Countdown continues!

We are happy to hear that folks are enjoying revisiting some of the older Deathly Hallows posts as we prepare for the release of part two of the final film! Since many folks have only just joined us in the last couple of years, some of these fossils are brand new for you!  We hope that you’ll explore some of the other treasures in the archives, not just ones setting up the final Harry film. We have some great treasures lurking in the past. Here’s a  fantastic little gem from three years ago, in which our beloved headmaster, who is certainly not in contention for head of the Hogwarts Faculty Film Fanciers Society, makes some lovely points about the relationship between films and the books on which they are based, with some very fine points for us to ponder while we wait in virtual line on Fandango. Enjoy!

DH:II Film Countdown 2

So, as promised, we are dusting off some of our “greatest hits” of Deathly Hallows Posts, in case you missed them the first time out, or in case a nasty Memory charm backfired and obliterated your recollection of them. Here  is a great “bonus” post–thirty of the threads from the novel’s intial release in 2007. Remember those days? I was still drinking cocoa and trying to recover. Enjoy this great visit down memory lane, with posts on subjects from symbolism to fairy tales to  reader reaction back when the last book was big news! As we get ready to revisit the last half of the story via the cinema, we can revist some of these great ideas, too! Enjoy! And don’t forget to send in those requests!