Hogwarts Professor

The latest brouhaha involving Rowling and the Transphobia Thought Police online oddly enough features an institution that features in one of her novels, perhaps the best single piece she has written to date, namely, Troubled Blood. Let’s quickly review the scandal at Skegness and how all the usual players in the ‘Transgender Thespian Troupe’ have said their formulaic lines before noting Rowling’s connection to the venue in question (and the likelihood she has been there in person).

In brief, Rowling tweeted out her disappointment that Butlins in Skegness had responded with deferential apologies to critics of how their security staff had removed biological men from a women’s restroom at that resort. Per The Independent:

Jae Roberts, one of the transgender women who claims to have been forcibly removed by security, shared a post on Instagram explaining her version of events.

“Butlins security just dragged five trans people out of the women’s toilets. Got slammed against a wall and dragged downstairs for intervening,” she said.

Roberts alleged she and the other trans women were asked to leave the toilet by security, which sparked chants of “let them pee”. She then claimed guards had returned with “reinforcements”, who began to forcibly remove the trans women from the bathroom.

A spokesperson for Butlin’s said: “We were very concerned to hear about this incident. Much to our disappointment, our third-party security contractor did not follow our processes despite being thoroughly briefed.

“Once we were made aware they were immediately removed from duty for not handling the situation in line with our processes. We are in direct contact with those involved and are reviewing how we work with contractors.”

The company added the security guard’s suspension had nothing to do with the trans women’s gender identity but the manner in which they were allegedly removed from the toilet.

Rowling responded to this bending-of-the-knee to those who believe that biological men “identifying” as women have the right to female-only spaces by tweeting them to clarify their policies so holiday goers would know where they want to spend their money, i.e., ‘Tell the world whether you’re on board with men in women’s spaces or not so those who agree with you can choose Butlins for their holidays and those who disagree will not.’ Her words were:

Does Butlins think the desire of cross-dressing men to enter women-only spaces is more important than women’s and girls’ right to privacy and dignity? Hopefully Butlins will explain their policy, so women and families can make an informed choice about where to go on holiday.

This is, in essence, the threat of a boycott by the great majority of people who do not want women and girls to have to share restrooms with biological men. Butlins is in a jam because they tried to thread the needle of not offending the “transgender” population or the media elite who champion this group’s “rights” while maintaining its policy that men are not allowed in their women’s restrooms.

The “usual suspects,” of course, promptly castigated Rowling for “frothing up rage” against a persecuted minority and for once again demonstrating to all the world that she is “transphobic.” (The successful weaponization of supposed phobias by same sex attraction champions and Muslims is of course being mimicked by “transgenderism” advocacy groups, with similar if relatively muted results.) Those who believe Rowling is a bigot and bully were confirmed in their opinion and her fans on the Gender Critical side of this controversy once again rallied to her flag.

If this Skegness Scandal has any future repercussions, then, it will be in how public venues choose to respond. Will they tell their security contractors to let the “transgender women” who are biological men to use women’s restrooms lest they suffer the bad publicity consequent to enforcing that space as a women’s only place? Or will they take the much harder course of guaranteeing the safety of their women’s restrooms in order to avoid being castigated by J. K. Rowling on her twixter feed to more than 14 million followers, a drubbing that will be carried as a feature story by media outlets locally and globally?

For struggling venues such as Butlins, reduced to three parks from a high of ten, this is a tough choice; it’s a lose-lose, frankly, for them which is a real victory for sanity in public spaces. Rowling has succeeded in insuring that their choosing to do the easy thing and fold to “transgender” bullying will experience an economic consequence at least equal to the loss of -TQ business. If there is “news” in this otherwise meaningless tabloid fodder, it is that Rowling is taking a new tack in her offensive to restore women’s rights in the UK, a decidedly economic push to prod businesses to stand up to bullies and do the right thing.

For those of us who are Rowling Readers, this is news to file away for future reference because, of all the ‘Golden Threads’ that run through her work start to finish, the most obvious and undeniable is ‘Violence Against Women.’ Rowling’s extracurricular crusade to champion the rights of women and children contra the rip tide of “transgender” over-reach is in lock step with a constant plot-point and theme in everything she has written.

This specific story, though, has the extra attraction for Rowling Readers of involving a location, Skegness’ beach resort, which Cormoran Strike and Robin Ellacott visit during Troubled Blood, and a business, Butlins, at which a murder occurs in the same novel.

One of the suspects in the disappearance and suspected murder of Margot Bamborough, M.D., was Steve Douthwaite. The Strike Agency expends significant effort in locating Douthwaite forty years after that crime and finally find and confront him in Skegness, where he works for his wife’s Bed-and-Breakfast inn for holiday goers. One of the landmark conversations that Robin and Strike have in the course of their relationship takes place looking out over the sea in Skegness after their interview with Douthwaite, now ‘Diamond,’ in which Strike sings ‘Trelawney’ to his partner and reveals his fealty to Cornwall.

And Butlins? After the police realized that Douthwaite was not a credible suspect in the 1974 Bamborough disappearance, he changed his name to ‘Jacks’ and took a job at the Butlins in Clacton-On-Sea, an east of London resort that has since closed. While there, though, Carl Oakden tracked him down for his book about Margot Bamborough from which source Janice Beattie learned his new name, ‘Stevie Jacks,’ and where he was hiding. She visited him and promptly murdered the young woman he fancied in order to send him a message. He got the message, changed his name again, this time to ‘Steve Diamond,’ and got a new Red Coat job at the original and much larger Butlins holiday camp in Ingoldmells near Skegness in Lincolnshire, England. He met his wife Donna there and settled down to a life-in-hiding only punctuated by his serial sexual trysts with women. Peaceful, at least, until Strike tracked him down.

So, has Rowling visited the Butlins in Ingoldmells, Skegness, though it never appears in  Troubled Blood? My bet is that she has. She captures the flavor of the holiday camp and the life of a Red Coat in telling detail in Troubled Blood, so I think she has visited one. Of the three Butlins still in operation, the Clacton-on-Sea venue having closed and been demolished in 1983, the Bognor Regis location is probably closer to London than Ingoldmells, but Rowling clearly visited Skegness to capture its distinct qualities for the time Strike and Ellacott spend there in Troubled Blood. If I were a betting man, I’d wager that Rowling made a trip to the Ingoldmells Butlins and spoke to a few Red Coats.

Which would mean that her tweets this past week expressing her disappointment with Butlins in Skegness would have been colored by her knowledge of the place. In a case of art-anticipating-life, she had brought to life a cowardly male character of easy virtue as a Skegness Butlins Red Coat, a man who ran from doing the right thing in the Bamborough case because of his fear of crossing the murderous Janice Beattie. How curious that, in the here and now ‘real world,’ Rowling is calling to account the Skegness Butlins for their failing in courage and principle.